Your feedback is so smart and coherent and I love it. ♥.
I can't decide if I needed it to be a good story or not YES. Agreed. It would've been nice if it had been better, but that was the least of my worries.
I was iffy about the break-up scene, BUT, A) Gillian's acting ♥ ♥ ♥ and B) what you said. It didn't become this big thing about getting back together, they just naturally knew that they couldn't REALLY leave each other.
The Samantha thing... was weird. And quite possibly my biggest problem, which I guess isn't a bad thing. But from the moment that scene was up before the movie came out, it rubbed me the wrong way. You're absolutely right in everything you said about that. BUT OMG, what Vanessa Morley cameo? Where was that???
Your paragraph about the show and what it means to you? Was beautiful. ♥
(oh... incidentally, I loved it. Is it odd that I understand most of people's criticisms but I still just... loved it? LOL IDK.)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2008-07-27 12:43 am (UTC)I can't decide if I needed it to be a good story or not YES. Agreed. It would've been nice if it had been better, but that was the least of my worries.
I was iffy about the break-up scene, BUT, A) Gillian's acting ♥ ♥ ♥ and B) what you said. It didn't become this big thing about getting back together, they just naturally knew that they couldn't REALLY leave each other.
The Samantha thing... was weird. And quite possibly my biggest problem, which I guess isn't a bad thing. But from the moment that scene was up before the movie came out, it rubbed me the wrong way. You're absolutely right in everything you said about that. BUT OMG, what Vanessa Morley cameo? Where was that???
Your paragraph about the show and what it means to you? Was beautiful. ♥
(oh... incidentally, I loved it. Is it odd that I understand most of people's criticisms but I still just... loved it? LOL IDK.)